Some wisdom pearls from B. Selic on modeling / UML at SFM12
I had the chance to listen to Bran Selic giving the opening lecture at the SFM´12 summer school . Since some of the tweets I wrote during the talk became quite popular, I thought it would be interesting to recap all of them in this blog post. Of course, when reading them keep in mind these are just tweets, not a summary of his talk so try not to over-interpret them. Anyway, I´ll be more than happy to provide more background or discuss about them so please share your views!
- Executing a model in your head is not nearly as good as having the machine executing it for you
- Fragmentation problem: combining independently defined DSLs in a coherent whole
- small languages solve small problems
- I can give you 1000 examples of UML being bad but “uml is big” is not one of them. Too big for what?
- Designing a language is the easy part. Creating all the tools around it is the challenging one #SFM12
- success criteria for a lang: technical validity, expressiveness, simplicity, run-time efficiency, familiarity, infrastructure
- key modeling language design issues: scope, abstraction range, precision level, model type, model of computation, extension #SFM12
- Feature models are a clear example of badly designed concrete syntax #SFM12
- PIM vs PSM is a bad idea. Platform is a relative concept. Which platforms are you independent of?
- MDE is not about graphical vs textual syntaxes
- MDE is not a new paradigm shift #SFM12
- MDE is based on two proven ideas: abstraction and automation
- Wouldn’t be nice that code smells would actually smell? You´d hurry up to refactor!!
- Proof that round-trip engineering is an awful idea. How do you build a pig from its sausages? (attributes it to @kthoms)
- New generation of ML – formal lang. designed for modeling (both descriptive and prescriptive models)
- The worst UML book you can buy is “UML Distilled” (the criticism refers to the fact that the book only covers the syntax of UML)
- Modeling tools are awful, tool creators don’t have a good understanding of who the users of the tools are
- UML is the worst modeling language except for all the others
By the way, the (tutorial) papers written by the lecturers (including my OCL tutorial) are available in M. Bernardo, V. Cortellessa, and A. Pierantonio (Eds.): SFM 2012, LNCS 7320.
If you liked this post, you should subscribe to the blog feed or facebook page and follow my thoughts on twitter about software development or web design and social media .